Tuesday, February 19, 2019

I-66 and Its Current Widening is Eroding the W&OD Trail Along Four Mile Run


February 12, 2019

The Honorable Christian Dorsey, Chairman
The Honorable Libby Garvey, Vice Chair
The Honorable Eric Gutshall, Member
The Honorable Katie Cristol, Member
The Honorable Matt de Ferranti, Member
Arlington County Board
Ellen M. Bozman Government Center
2100 Clarendon Blvd., Suite 300
Arlington, VA  22201r

            Re:  I-66 Widening Project Impacts on Four Mile Run and the W&OD Trail

Dear Members of the County Board:

            As residents of the Madison Manor Civic Association (MMCA) and members of the Arlington Coalition for Sensible Transportation (ACST), we write today to express our concern about excess stormwater runoff associated with the I-66 Inside the Beltway widening project that is causing serious damage to Four Mile Run, the W&OD Trail, and negatively impacting the community.

            Over the past two years, MMCA has had several meetings with the Virginia Department of Transportation (VDOT) regarding the I-66 widening project.  In addition to concerns about noise and increased emissions associated with the project, MMCA, ACST, and a number of residents have expressed concerns about stormwater runoff and the impact on Four Mile Run and other neighborhood facilities.  Specifically, the MMCA and ACST have noted that current VDOT stormwater facilities do not meet current building specifications, are currently underperforming due to inadequate and frequently clogged intake facilities, and will be negatively impacted by the widening project.

            The County Board has also expressed similar concerns to VDOT.  In a January 28, 2017, Board Resolution regarding the I-66 widening project, the Board specifically requested that VDOT ensure that “any new stormwater management facilities proposed with this project be adequately maintained, specifically that erosion and sediment controls should be outlined and contain information on inspection and enforcement actions.”

            Unfortunately, our concerns about damage due to increased runoff have recently manifested themselves in erosion on Four Mile Run that is threatening a portion of the W&OD Trail between Ohio Street and George Mason Drive with imminent collapse.  It is our understanding that the County intends to close a portion of the W&OD Trail on or about February 18, 2019, for an emergency repair project.  While we appreciate the County taking rapid action to fix the Trail, we are concerned about the impact the detour will have on adjoining neighborhoods (and especially children who use the Trail to get to schools) and the fact this appears to be a temporary fix paid for by Arlington taxpayers that will not involve any action by VDOT to prevent the excess runoff that is causing this problem in the first place.

            Accordingly, we urge the County Board to demand that VDOT take immediate action to fix its current underperforming stormwater system along the I-66 corridor and stop the degradation of Four Mile Run, the W&OD Trail, and other Arlington neighborhood assets in the Four Mile Run watershed.

Sincerely,





Dr. Alison Denton
President
Madison Manor Civic Association





Christopher Day
President
Arlington Coalition for Sensible Transportation



cc:  Virginia Department of Transportation

Tuesday, January 29, 2019

Statement to Prince William County State Legislators Regarding Toll Cheating on I-66 Inside the Beltway


 
Statement of Allen Muchnick to the 
Prince William Delegation to the Virginia General Assembly
January 5, 2019

I'm Allen Muchnick, a City of Manassas resident, speaking on my own behalf.  I’m concerned that HOV enforcement during the tolling of I-66 inside the Beltway has generally been inadequate.

VDOT’s alteration of the 36-year-old I-66 HOV restrictions to add congestion-priced tolls for solo motorists has generally been a substantial success.  It has increased ridesharing and express bus ridership, moving more people through the corridor.  During weekday commuting hours, traffic congestion on I-66 has largely ended, while congestion on alternative routes is essentially unchanged or lessened.  Moreover, at least $20 million/year of toll revenue is now being invested in multimodal corridor improvements, creating a virtuous cycle.

Despite the outcry over “exorbitant tolls”, about two-thirds of the people who use I-66 during tolling are carpoolers or bus riders who pay no toll at all.  That share is even greater when the toll prices are highest.

Nevertheless, no project is perfect, and I’m concerned that many drive-alone motorists have been unlawfully cheating the I-66 tolls, by improperly sliding an E-ZPass Flex transponder to the "HOV setting".

Such toll cheating is unfair to all law-abiding I-66 travelers and raises the prices charged to those who do pay those tolls.  Moreover, since toll cheaters are immune to the variable pricing message,  toll cheating likely contributes to the notoriously high ($40-plus) peak AM I-66 tolls, is greatest when the tolls are highest, and causes some I-66 congestion that delays ridesharers, bus passengers, and toll-paying motorists.

Since mid-2012, VDOT consistently told the public that the change from HOV-2+ to high-occupancy/tolling would effectively end the previously rampant HOV cheating by solo motorists.  To that end, the previously lawful HOV exemptions for drivers traveling to or from Dulles Airport and for vehicles with grandfathered clean fuel license plates were finally ended, and VDOT now dedicates at least $550,000/year of I-66 toll revenue to constantly station at least four State Troopers along I-66 during tolling, presumably to vigorously enforce the HOV-2+ requirement for a toll-free trip.

To understand the nature and extent of HOV enforcement during tolling, I requested information from the Virginia State Police (VSP).  I’ve learned that VSP does not report or collect much useful data on HOV enforcement and has no estimate of HOV violations. 

According to VSP, no special HOV-enforcement initiatives were conducted during the first 51 weeks of tolling.  A "targeted HOV enforcement" initiative on November 30, 2018 resulted in 32 HOV-violation summonses, despite considerable advance publicity.  A second such initiative, also with advance publicity, was conducted on December 13, 2018.

During the first 53 weeks of tolling, only 702 HOV-violation summonses were issued during routine HOV enforcement on 253 tolling days.  Thus, on average, only 2.77 HOV-violation summonses were issued for every 8 hours of tolling.

According to VDOT, I-66 averages more than 33,000 vehicle trips/day during the eight daily tolling hours with 42.3% of those trips (14,000 vehicle trips/day) using an E-ZPass Flex in the HOV mode.  Considering the high toll prices, especially from 7:30-9:00 am, it seems likely that far more than three solo motorists/day are cheating the tolls.  Even 99% HOV-compliance among the E-ZPass Flex users would yield 140 toll-cheating trips/day.  A WTOP report publishedyesterday suggests at least 400 toll-cheating trips/day.

HOV enforcement on I-66 is difficult and endangers both the trooper and the traveling public.  The trooper must visually observe the number of vehicle occupants and then pursue the suspected violator and initiate a traffic stop in dense freeway traffic.  Presently, the paved shoulders are often inadequate, especially eastbound.  At least 41% of the time, the chased and stopped suspect vehicle actually has two or more occupants, so no summons is warranted.

I-66 users deserve effective HOV enforcement, and similar problems may exist with all express toll lanes in Virginia.  In the short-term, VSP and VDOT should be required to routinely collect and report meaningful data on HOV enforcement.  I further recommend conducting a full, fair, and open study to determine whether automated vehicle occupancy detection and/or HOV-enforcement is feasible or whether exempting HOVs from tolling should be discontinued because effective HOV enforcement is impractical.

Thank you for holding this public hearing and for considering my comments.

Sunday, December 9, 2018

Incompetent and Biased WaPo Report Documents I-66 Toll Cheating Enforcement



This sensationalist and mindless Washington Post story on the one-year anniversary of I-66 tolling at least documents that the Virginia State Police have failed to effectively enforce against I-66 toll-cheating by solo motorists.

There is also evidence that some commuters are trying to cheat the system: solo drivers switching their E-ZPass transponder to carpool mode and hoping they don’t get caught. An enforcement blitz on the morning of Nov. 30 netted 13 citations for such commuters. In 10 months following the system’s opening, the state police issued 614 HOV violations, according to records.

Issuing 614 citations over 217 weekdays (which includes several non-tolled holidays) equates to fewer than 3 toll-cheating citations for every 8 hours of tolling.  With one-way full-trip toll prices often in the $20-$45 range and fewer than 3 cheating motorists being stopped on a typical day, it's likely that hundreds, if not thousands, of solo motorists have been cheating the I-66 tolls and driving up the toll prices for law-abiding toll payers.

The following passage in the article reveals the ignorance and bias of the authors.  The comment I posted on the WaPo webpage is copied below it.

The number of vehicles traveling with two or more people on I-66 inside the Beltway during tolling hours has increased 25 percent since January, to about 15,000 from about 12,000, according to the VDOT report. However, the majority of road users are still solo drivers who are paying tolls.
Sadly, the authors of this sensationalist smear job either don't understand the word "users" or are incompetent at grade-school arithmetic.  The "users" of I-66 are PEOPLE in cars and buses, not VEHICLES.   While the majority of vehicles on I-66 may have only one occupant, each carpool has two or more occupants and each bus probably averages 25 or more riders.  The 15,000 carpools equate to more than 30,000 people, while express buses using I-66 are now moving more than 6,000 people each day.  Clearly, the majority of I-66 USERS while tolling is in effect (at least 36,000 PEOPLE on an average workday) are carpoolers and bus riders who ride toll-free and now have faster and more reliable trips.  Failing to mention those important facts reveals the ignorance, professional incompetence, and simplistic solo-motorist bias of the authors.

Friday, July 13, 2018

Sensationalistic NBC4 Story on I-66 Tolls


 
On July 11, 2018, our Washington DC NBC4 station aired an unconscionable and sensationalistic two-minute "news" story titled "Lawmakers Consider Adding More I-66 Tolls", with the prominent tag line "Costly Commute" : [ https://www.nbcwashington.com/news/local/Lawmakers-Consider-Adding-More-I-66-Tolls-487932251.html ].

The story begins with a video clip of slow-moving, congested I-66 traffic (eastbound in the late afternoon just east of N Sycamore St), which of course is not how I-66 operates when tolling is in effect.  Introducing the story, news anchor Wendy Rieger says, amidst muffled laughter, "and now there is talk about putting even more tolls on one of our most notorious roads, the beloved I-66".

Local transportation reporter Adam Tuss then graphically reminds viewers of the notorious "sky-high" "near $50" I-66 tolls before asserting: "but now, now there's chatter about putting tolls on both inbound and outbound sections of the road during both rush hours".  The text version of the story states "...and now lawmakers are discussing adding more tolls on Interstate 66" in the "reverse-commute" direction. 

Oddly, this story fails to identify even one "lawmaker".  In fact, the only public official mentioned at all is Virginia Transportation Secretary Shannon Valentine, who is currently not a "lawmaker".

More critically, this story never bothers to say why I-66 is now tolled, much less explain that the congestion-priced tolling has created a virtuous cycle that 1) ensures fast and reliable trips for I-66 express bus passengers, carpoolers, and toll payers; 2) invests much of the new toll revenue in expanded multimodal travel options in the corridor that benefit the toll payers, and 3) is now moving many more people on our regional urban core's finite highway capacity--without diverting scarce transportation funds from other projects--and with no overall worsening of traffic congestion on nearby parallel roads.

Instead, the story primarily features "man on the street" reactions to more "sky-high" tolls from two motorists buying gasoline at the Exxon station at Lee Hwy and Washington Blvd in East Falls Church, in an attempt to illustrate strong public opposition to the "ripoff" tolls.  In doing so, this story merely perpetuates the public's ignorance of the many and substantial benefits of VDOT's Transform 66 initiative and exploits populist opposition to paying tolls.

Meanwhile, Tuss ignores the real-time I-66 tolling signs in the background which display westbound toll prices of only $1.50 to travel the two tolled I-66 segments from East Falls Church to I-495 South.

Although one of the interviewed motorists is a professional chauffeur who, of course, would pay no toll at all for a congestion-free trip whenever chauffeuring even one passenger, that fact isn't mentioned either.  His false remark that "only the rich can afford to drive, to be on the 66" is left unchallenged.  Surely, this chauffeur's passengers would prefer to avoid I-66 congestion during their trips and would not want their pickup times delayed by I-66 congestion either.

Critically, this sensationalistic story mentions none of these project benefits documented in VDOT's Transform66: Inside the Beltway Six-Month Performance Report (individual slides from this presentation are referenced below}:

1) Assuming only one passenger in every carpool and vanpool, a clear majority (at least 61%) of auto travelers using the tolled I-66 lanes--those in autos with two or more people--pay absolutely no toll at all (Slide 30).  Moreover, when the tolls are highest, the share of I-66 auto travelers who pay no toll at all is substantially higher than 61% (at least 74-81%; Slide 25 and May 2018 Performance Report).  Counting the 6,000+ express bus passengers from Loudoun, Prince William, and Fairfax Counties who now also travel toll-free (and faster) each workday on the tolled I-66 express lanes (see page 39 of this NVTC document), more than 65% of all I-66 express lane travelers are now enjoying toll-free trips, and fewer than 35% of the express lane travelers pay any toll at all.

2) The tolling regime is now moving thousands more people/day on I-66 during the tolling hours (more than 5,100 additional vehicles in May 2018 vs January 2018, nearly half of which are HOV2+; Slide 30) and with no overall degradation (actually, a modest overall improvement) in the traffic congestion on nearby parallel arterial roads (Slides 9-12, 19-22).
 
3) The notorious, "sky-high" AM tolls are charged only during the peak of the former HOV2+ hours (i.e., 7:30-9:00 AM), when the proportion of carpools is highest and most solo motorists could not lawfully use I-66 at all before the tolling was implemented.  From 5:30-6:30 AM, the average eastbound toll has been less than $2.64 (Slide 25).

4) Only 0.28% of all I-66 toll payers paid more than $40 for a one-way trip during the first six months of tolling (Slide 24).

5) Since tolling began, crashes along I-66 have decreased 12.% eastbound and 15.0% westbound, saving lives, time, and money (Slide 34).

In addition, as the travel modeling in VDOT's 2015 Transform66 Tolling Study predicted, due to far less travel demand and HOV (toll-free) travel in the reverse-commute direction, reverse-commute tolls, if ever implemented, would have far lower average prices (e.g., 1/5th or less) than the current average toll prices in the peak direction only (see Slide 19 in that presentation).   Furthermore, even if many reverse commuters diverted from I-66 onto alternative routes, the excess reverse-commute capacity of those alternative routes would keep them from becoming severely congested.

Moreover, most solo motorists could readily use I-66 for free during tolling hours, simply by traveling with a prescreened passenger matched by a professional ridesharing service or a "slug" passenger waiting at a growing number of slugline locations.  In addition, ample nearby toll-free parallel expressways and arterial highways exist, and the time needed to drive those alternative routes is generally not substantially longer than using the congested I-66 prior to the tolling (e.g., 3.2  minutes longer to TR Bridge from EB I-66 @ I-495 via I-495 and Rte 50 at 6:00 AM [Slide 32], 1.9 minutes *shorter* to TR Bridge from EB VA-267 @ I-495 via I-495 and GWMP to TR Bridge [Slide 33]) .  In other words, nobody is forced to pay the I-66 tolls, and hardly anyone is unduly penalized by avoiding the tolls.  Paying the I-66 tolls is entirely a choice, and thousands of additional motorists have begun voluntarily paying those tolls in recent months in exchange for a faster and more reliable trip.

Tuss also fails to note that the proposal to toll I-66 inside the Beltway in both directions, during peak weekday hours only, is hardly new.  It was a fundamental recommendation in VDOT's 2011-2013 I-66 Multimodal Study and an integral part of VDOT's Transform 66 planning process until Governor McAuliffe removed it in October 2015, a few weeks before a general election for the entire Virginia General Assembly.  In addition, during the 2018 Virginia General Assembly session, several legislators filed bills and/or budget amendments to initiate I-66 tolling in the reverse-commute direction, although all such bills and budget amendments ultimately failed.  Clearly, the objective of this story was to spin up viewers, not to report any real news.

NBC4's website touts "Adam Tuss and the News4 team" as "covering everything that slows you down on roads and transit", but this "news team" failed miserably at explaining the many virtues of VDOT's Transform I-66 congestion-pricing program; namely, that it has vastly improved both motorist and express bus speeds and already moves many more people along the corridor, with no diversion of scarce federal or state transportation funds from other projects or programs or any other public expenditures.

In short, this despicable "news" story was produced solely to generate controversy, not to enlighten the public or better people's lives.   We must tell NBC4 management that such "yellow journalism" is clearly unacceptable and demand that NBC4 air a full and fair rebuttal to this unbalanced I-66 tolling story.

Thursday, January 11, 2018

Bills Filed for the 2018 Session of the Virginia General Assembly to Limit or Stop the Tolling of I-66 Inside the Beltway








Summary as introduced:
HOT lanes on Interstate 66; operating hours. Sets the operating hours for HOT lanes on Interstate 66 inside the Beltway from 6:30 a.m. to 9:00 a.m. on the eastbound lanes and from 4:00 p.m. to 6:30 p.m. on the westbound lanes.

Saturday, January 6, 2018

Statement to Prince William County Delegation to the Virginia General Assembly, January 6, 2018



I’m Allen Muchnick, a City of Manassas resident.  I’ve helped lead the Arlington Coalition for Sensible Transportation since 1999.  The following remarks are my own.

Most of you oppose the recent congestion-priced tolling of I-66 inside the Beltway, but that opposition is misguided and counterproductive.  After spending the past 18 years fighting for a wiser I-66 inside the Beltway, I’m quite familiar with all the arguments against the tolls and would be happy to meet with any of you to discuss this issue.  For now, here are some facts:

I-66 inside the Beltway is the most controversial Interstate highway segment ever built, has two Metrorail lines in its median, and has always had peak-period HOV restrictions.   The congestion-priced tolls merely replace the former HOV restrictions, which had failed to keep I-66 free-flowing for express buses and carpools due to several HOV exemptions and rampant HOV cheating.

NOBODY is forced to pay these tolls.  Ample toll-free alternative routes exist inside the Beltway, including the Route 50 and GWMP expressways.  Those who formerly drove on I-66 before or after the former HOV hours, often at 30 MPH or less, are not inordinately delayed by using an alternative route, and they now have the option of traveling I-66 at 55 MPH by paying the toll or carpooling.

The new I-66 tolls are less unfair than the tolls on the I-495 or I-95 express lanes:  only one passenger is needed for toll-free travel, and the bulk of the toll revenue is being invested in transit (including PRTC bus and VRE), ride-sharing, roadway, and other multimodal I-66 corridor improvements that benefit the toll payers.   Moreover, without this tolling, widening I-66 both outside and inside the Beltway would be politically and financially infeasible.

The toll prices are irrelevant; they are the minimum needed to keep I-66 free flowing for express buses and carpools.  Save your outrage for the decades of congestion delay endured by I- 66 bus riders and carpoolers.  Save your outrage for the decades of inadequate support of bus transit and ridesharing by Prince William’s elected officials.

Thank you for your time and attention.

Monday, December 11, 2017

I-66 Toll Prices Are Not Exorbitant



An examination of the "historical" toll prices for I-66 inside-the-Beltway, archived at [ https://vai66tolls.com/# ], shows that VDOT's 2015 estimate of $17 daily round-trip tolls was reasonably accurate, especially for the hours before the former HOV-2 restrictions.

Public attention has largely focused on the high "peak of the peak" tolls, but those high tolls occurred during the former HOV-2 hours (6:30 am-9:00 am eastbound and 4:00 pm-6:30 pm westbound), when most I-66 traffic had formerly been carpools (which should be accommodated and kept free-flowing) and the former SOV traffic had been HOV cheaters and those with outdated legal exemptions.

Many of those objecting to the high I-66 tolls cite concerns for those commuters (often from the outer suburbs) who formerly drove solo on I-66 between 5:30 am and 6:30 am eastbound and between 3:00 pm and 4:00 pm westbound to avoid the previous HOV restrictions.  Tolling opponents claim that carpooling is infeasible for many outer suburban I-66 commuters, slugging has been practically nonexistent, and viable bus transit options often don't exist.

According to the archived toll prices at [ https://vai66tolls.com/#  ], the toll prices last week for the full eastbound trip (Capital Beltway to Washington DC) at 6:00 am and at 6:15 am were as follows:

Date                Price at 6:00 AM             Price at 6:15 AM
12/4 (M)                $9.75                                    $12.75
12/5 (Tu)               $7.00                                      $6.25
12/6 (W)                $7.50                                      $7.50
12/7 (Th)               $7.25                                      $6.50
12/8 (F)                 $7.00                                      $6.75

The toll prices last week for a full westbound trip (Washington DC to the Capital Beltway) at 3:30 pm and 4:00 pm were as follows:

Date                Price at 3:30 PM             Price at 4:00 PM
12/4 (M)                $7.00                                      $6.25
12/5 (Tu)               $7.00                                      $6.50
12/6 (W)                $8.00                                      $6.75
12/7 (Th)               $7.25                                      $6.50
12/8 (F)                 $6.75                                      $6.75

These prices, which may decline in the coming weeks as some solo I-66 drivers modify their route, travel time, or mode to avoid or reduce their tolls, are comparable to the cost of parking at an outer Orange Line station and taking Metrorail downtown, so few of these motorists will switch to slower and less convenient Metrorail, especially if they have free parking at work.

For those SOV commuters who wish to continue to drive alone and avoid all tolls, several nearby toll-free arterial highways remain available for the roughly 10-mile trip between the Capital Beltway and downtown Washington DC, including Routes 29, 50, 123, and the George Washington Memorial Parkway.  Even at an average overall speed of 30 MPH (a common speed for I-66 before the tolling), a 10-mile trip on an alternative route should add only about 10 minutes to a commuter's travel time, compared to the free-flowing I-66.  Moreover, as more I-66 commuters switch to ridersharing or transit or choose to now drive solo on I-66 and pay the toll, these alternative, toll-free routes should see less, not more, traffic.